Is This Website Legit? How to Check an Online Shop Before You Pay

Safety & scams Guide8 min read·Updated November 12, 2026

This article is for general information only and is not financial advice. For decisions that affect your money, speak with a qualified financial professional.

The short answer

No single tool can prove an online shop is honest, and a chatbot that can't look the site up live is only guessing. Combine a few quick checks: read the web address letter by letter, check who is behind the shop, run it through a website checker such as ScamAdviser or Ask Silver, and search the shop's name with words like "review" or "scam". Pause before paying, pay by credit card if you can, and walk away if the shop wants a gift card, bank transfer or cryptocurrency. If you already paid, contact your card issuer the same day.

You found the perfect coat, or a gift at half the usual price, on a shop you have never heard of — maybe through a search, maybe scrolling past an ad on Facebook or Instagram. Before you type in your card number, it is worth spending two minutes on checks. Fake shops multiply before Black Friday and the holidays, and free AI tools now make it cheap to build a professional-looking website, product photos and descriptions in minutes.

The good news: you do not need technical skills. You need a few habits.

Can ChatGPT tell me if a website is real?

Not on its own. A general chatbot that cannot open the page or look up reports about the shop has little to go on, so its verdict is a guess, even when it sounds confident. That is our reading of how these tools work, not a quote from a study, so treat the chatbot as a helper for asking questions, not as a judge.

Tools built for this job do better, because they actually visit the site and check what is known about it. They still make mistakes, and a skilled scammer can fool them. That is why we suggest combining checks.

Check 1: Read the web address, then run it through a checker

Tap or click the address bar and read the address slowly, letter by letter — not the logo or name shown in an ad, which can say anything. Fake shops copy well-known brands with small changes: an extra word (brandname-outlet), a different ending (.shop, .store or .top instead of .com), or a swapped letter. If you reached the shop from an ad or a message, type the real brand's address yourself, or search for it, and compare.

Then copy the address (from the address bar, not from the ad or message) and paste it into a checker. Which?, the UK consumer organisation, picks out two free options:

  • ScamAdviser gives a trust score for a website, phone number or crypto address, built from various online data sources. A score tells you how likely a site is to be trustworthy. It is not certainty.
  • Ask Silver uses AI to check images, websites, text messages and phone numbers for signs of a scam, in under 30 seconds, against known scam sources.

Which? warns that these free tools may not spot the signs of a sophisticated scam. A good score is a green light to keep checking, not to pay.

Check 2: Search for what other people say

Search the shop's name and web address together with words like review, complaint or scam. The FTC, the US consumer protection agency, recommends exactly this. Read a few results, not just the first, and look outside the shop's own pages. No results at all is also a warning sign for a shop that claims thousands of happy customers. Remember that reviews can be fake as well, so see how to spot fake AI-generated product reviews.

Also look at the shop itself:

  • Can you find who runs it? A real shop names the company, gives a postal address, a phone number or email, and clear return and refund rules. If you cannot find any of these, think twice.
  • Is the "About us" text vague, or do the photos and reviews look too perfect? Stock or AI-generated photos, reviews that are all glowing and oddly similar, and comments switched off under the shop's ads are all signs worth a second look.
  • Is the price too good to be true? The FTC lists unusually low prices as a warning sign, especially a deep discount on a popular item with a countdown timer or "only 2 left" attached.

Check 3: Pause before you pay

Scammers want you to hurry: "only 2 left", "sale ends in 10 minutes". Take five minutes anyway. This is sometimes called the "Take Five" rule, which Which? also points to: stop and think before paying or sharing sensitive details.

The way you pay matters just as much:

  • Use a credit card if you have one, including through a payment service you already trust. The FTC says that if you are double-charged, billed for something that never arrived or sent the wrong item, you can dispute the charge with your card company. In the EU, card issuers are often not legally required to reverse a charge, but VISA and Mastercard rules mean many banks do it voluntarily for goods that never arrive — act within a few months, since schemes usually set a deadline. A bank transfer, by contrast, usually cannot be reversed this way.
  • Walk away if the shop insists on a gift card, wire transfer, payment app or cryptocurrency. The FTC says that is probably a scam, because those payments are very hard to get back. Do not save your card details in a shop you do not already know.

Local lists you can use

Some countries publish their own warning lists. They are only as good as the reports behind them, but they are worth a look:

  • Czech Republic: the Czech Trade Inspection Authority (ČOI) keeps a public list of risky online shops. It says the list is not complete and a listing is only a recommendation to consumers.
  • Germany: the consumer advice centres (Verbraucherzentrale) offer a free Fakeshop-Finder.
  • Austria: Watchlist Internet publishes a list of fake shops and lets you report suspicious ones.

If your country is not listed, search for your national consumer authority plus "fake online shops". Do not rely on a site that only appears in an ad.

If something looks wrong

If a shop fails your checks, close the page. If you already paid:

  1. Call your card issuer or bank today and ask for a chargeback.
  2. Save the evidence: screenshots of the ad, the website, your order and any emails.
  3. Change passwords you used on that site, and watch your statement for further charges.
  4. Report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov (US) or your national consumer or police fraud service.

Our guide I sent money to a scammer: what to do in the first 24 hours has the full list.

What to try next

Shops are not the only place scammers hide. See QR code scams and fake travel bookings. If you are thinking about letting an AI do the buying, read how safe AI shopping agents are first.

Sources

Published October 22, 2026 · Updated November 12, 2026How we test →

Frequently asked questions

Can I just ask ChatGPT whether a website is safe?
Not as your only check. A chatbot that cannot look the site up live has nothing to go on except the address and what it remembers, so its answer is a guess that can sound very sure. Some tools are built to visit the page and look for reports, which is a better starting point, and even those can miss a well-made fake.
Can I trust a shop just because it looks professional?
No. Free AI tools can produce polished product photos, descriptions and even reviews in minutes, so a good-looking site proves nothing by itself. What matters is who stands behind it: a named company, a real address, clear return rules and independent opinions from outside the shop's own pages.
If a website checker gives a good score, is the shop safe?
No. A score shows how likely a site is to be trustworthy, not a guarantee. Which? points out that free tools cannot catch everything, which is why the pause before paying matters most.
What is the safest way to pay a shop I don't know?
A credit card, where you have one. The FTC says that if you are double-charged, billed for something that never arrived or sent the wrong item, you can dispute the charge with your card company. In the EU, card issuers are often not legally required to reverse a charge but many do it voluntarily, so act within a few months. Be suspicious if a seller insists on a gift card, wire transfer, payment app or cryptocurrency.
A shop isn't on any scam list. Does that mean it's fine?
No. Lists only contain shops that someone has already reported or that officials have already looked at. The Czech Trade Inspection Authority, for example, says its own list of risky online shops is not complete, so a shop missing from it is not proof that it is safe.
What should I do if I already paid a fake shop?
Contact your bank or card company straight away, tell them you are reporting a fraudulent payment, and ask for a chargeback. Save screenshots of the ad, the website and your order, and change any password you used on the site. Speed matters. Our guide on what to do in the first 24 hours walks you through it step by step.
Radim S.
Founder & editor

Radim is a software developer who spends his days building with AI and his evenings explaining it to family members who don’t care how it works — only what it can do for them. The safety guides are checked claim by claim against primary sources before they go out.